Reviews You Can Rely On

Janome MOD-19 Review

This average sewing machine has a higher price tag, but it's good for those who like to take their time with things
gearlab tested logo
Janome MOD-19 Review (A basic sewing machine for a moderate to larger budget.)
A basic sewing machine for a moderate to larger budget.
Credit: Abriah Wofford
Price:  $399 List
  • 1
  • 2
  • 3
  • 4
  • 5
Manufacturer:   Janome
By Austin Palmer and Ruth Bruckbauer  ⋅  Jun 12, 2023
57
OVERALL
SCORE


RANKED
#14 of 15
  • Sewing - 45% 6.6
  • Ease of use - 35% 5.6
  • Buttonholes - 20% 3.6

Our Verdict

Janome has a favorable name and image in most sewing circles, but unfortunately, the Janome MOD-19 fell short of many of its siblings. The setup directions are molded onto the machine, which means they're handy but not very readable; the sewing test results were uninspiring; and the buttonholes, though somewhat easy to set up, were of poorer quality. Most of the directions are in the manual, so you'll spend some time going between the machine and the manual, but once you figure it out, it should be fine. An experienced sewer would be able to figure out and use this sewing machine without a problem, but it could be too overwhelming for a novice.
REASONS TO BUY
Top-load bobbin with printed instructions
Great needle threader
REASONS TO AVOID
Plastic bobbin winder with plastic clip
Subpar bobbin winding

Compare to Similar Products

 
janome mod-19
This Product
Janome MOD-19
Awards  Editors' Choice Award
Best Overall Sewing Machine for Most People
Top Pick Award
Best High-Value Buttonhole Maker
 Best Buy Award
Best Bang for Your Buck
Price $399 List
$179.00 at Amazon
$260 List
$259.99 at Amazon
$300 List$240 List
$239.99 at Amazon
$150 List
$129.99 at Amazon
Overall Score Sort Icon
57
79
75
75
72
Star Rating
  • 1
  • 2
  • 3
  • 4
  • 5
  • 1
  • 2
  • 3
  • 4
  • 5
  • 1
  • 2
  • 3
  • 4
  • 5
  • 1
  • 2
  • 3
  • 4
  • 5
  • 1
  • 2
  • 3
  • 4
  • 5
Bottom Line This model has a high price tag for just being an average sewing machineA simple to use option with lots of stitches, an excellent screen, and an affordable price, but isn't the cleanest buttonhole makerThis is a great machine for just about everyone, although a serious sewist may want a machine with better quality stitchingA user-friendly model that works well on all the basics except for buttonholes, and comes at an affordable priceA beginner would really like this machine since it's easy-to-use and inexpensive
Rating Categories Janome MOD-19 Brother HC1850 Singer 7258 Stylist Brother CS7000X Brother CS5055
Sewing (45%)
6.6
7.8
7.5
7.4
6.8
Ease of use (35%)
5.6
9.3
7.8
9.2
8.0
Buttonholes (20%)
3.6
5.6
7.2
4.8
6.8
Specs Janome MOD-19 Brother HC1850 Singer 7258 Stylist Brother CS7000X Brother CS5055
# of Built-in Stitches 19 185 100 70 60
# of Buttonhole Styles 1 8 6 7 7
Automatic Bobbin Winder Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes
Manufacturer Stated Maximum Sewing Speed (stitches per minute) 800 850 750 750 750
Computerized? No Yes Yes Yes Yes
Buttonhole Sewing (number of steps) 4-Step 1-Step 1-Step 1-Step 1-Step
Maximum Stitch Width 5mm 7mm 6mm 7mm 7mm
Maximum Stitch Length 4mm 5mm 4.8mm 5mm 5mm
Thread Cutter Built-in Built-in Built-in Built-in Built-in
Cover No No Soft Hard No
Free Arm Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes
Measured Weight 11.8 Ibs 10.5 lbs 14.6 lbs 10.4 lbs 10.8 lbs

Our Analysis and Test Results

Janome sewing machines have been around a good number of years and have a loyal following among sewers. The Janome MOD-19 will have a loyal following, too, thanks to its above-average sewing results. However, some other things will leave many Janome brand lovers shaking their heads.

Performance Comparison


janome mod-19 - dials help you choose which of the 19 different stitches to use.
Dials help you choose which of the 19 different stitches to use.
Credit: Abriah Wofford

Sewing


Our test team put the MOD-19 sewing machine through its paces. From the basic straight stitch all the way to the scallop stitch, everything was tested, measured, and reported. Overall, the MOD-19 came out slightly above average for this metric. The tension was a little tight, causing a lot of bunching with chiffon, but satin, silk, and cotton jersey all looked pretty good. Some little bottom threads popped up here and there, but nothing that would cause big problems.

janome mod-19 - the stitching looked pretty good on the quilting test fabric.
The stitching looked pretty good on the quilting test fabric.
Credit: Abriah Wofford

Then we came to the zigzag stitch. People tend to overlook this stitch, thinking that they'll never use it. But a zigzag is the foundation of many decorative stitches, not to mention buttonholes, which is why we test it so thoroughly. Overall, the MOD-19 did pretty well with the zigzag stitch, although it did have some bunching problems with chiffon. But almost every machine has some bunching problems with chiffon, so we consider that too. Overall, the MOD-19 scored slightly better in our sewing tests than the other Janomes we tested but lower in some other categories. Our sewing tests comprise 45% of the final score for each machine.

janome mod-19 - the different stitches are clearly defined and easy to adjust...
The different stitches are clearly defined and easy to adjust. Simply turn the dial to get the desired stitch.
Credit: Abriah Wofford

Ease of Use


A sewing machine will not be fully enjoyed (or even used) if the process is overly difficult. We place 35% of the total scoring on how easy each machine is to set up and use. We look at different areas: stitch setup, bobbin, threading the needle, the thread cutter, lighting, and needle stop position. Overall, the Janome MOD-19 did exceptionally well at threading the needle and very well with the thread cutter and lighting. The other areas were below average, with the needle stop position being far below average.

janome mod-19 - it's a little complicated getting this machine ready to sew, but...
It's a little complicated getting this machine ready to sew, but once you understand the system, you'll be fine.
Credit: Abriah Wofford

As it turns out, the MOD-19 doesn't have a complicated list of stitches, but there is no clear explanation on the machine for what any of the numbers or symbols on the dials mean. That said, the instruction manual explains how to set the machine up and how to use the dials, so once you've done it a couple of times, you'll be fine. And the bobbin has clear directions on it for how to insert it into the bobbin holder once it's wound.

The wound bobbins show a little inconsistency.
The wound bobbins show a little inconsistency.
A top loading bobbin is so much easier to use that a front-loading...
A top loading bobbin is so much easier to use that a front-loading one.
Loading the bobbins into the machine required some trial and error to get them even.

Buttonholes


Ah, buttonholes. The bane of many a sewer. Some will even go to great lengths to avoid putting in a buttonhole. But a clean, neat buttonhole goes a long way toward a beautifully finished garment.

janome mod-19 - clear results of the buttonholes on several different machines.
Clear results of the buttonholes on several different machines.
Credit: Abriah Wofford

This sewing machine was the only one we tested with a 4-step buttonhole process; the others all have a 1-step buttonhole. But all is not lost because the 4-step buttonhole is easier than average to set up and use. However, it can be tedious as you'll have to lay the button on the garment, mark the top and bottom, then add some length so the button can go through. Our testers recommend drawing your line on the back side of your garment — you'll likely need to practice a bit before you get the hang of doing it. It's not a terrible process, and it even works better than some of the 1-step buttonholes we tested. And as one of our testers noted, “It gets the job done.”

janome mod-19 - choosing a buttonhole size before getting started.
Choosing a buttonhole size before getting started.
Credit: Abriah Wofford

Should You Buy the Janome MOD-19?


Well, we tested other sewing machines that were easier to set up and use and also cheaper. We do not think that the MOD-19 would be a good beginner sewing machine, nor is it for everybody, especially those who always want the latest and greatest. But it may be a good fit for a veteran sewer who has the money and isn't afraid to take the time to figure things out.

janome mod-19 - the mod-19 requires a little more finagling to get the settings...
The MOD-19 requires a little more finagling to get the settings right than many others we tested.
Credit: Abriah Wofford

What Other Sewing Machines Should You Consider?


If you are a Janome fan, both the Janome MOD-50 and the Janome 3160QDC-T performed better in our tests. You'll have to shell out a little more, but you'll likely be much happier in the long run. If you are open to other brands and would appreciate something a little more user-friendly, the Brother HC1850 is an excellent choice that costs less. If you're okay with paying a premium price, the Singer 9960 Quantum Stylist performed excellently in all our testing metrics.

Austin Palmer and Ruth Bruckbauer