Our Verdict
Compare to Similar Products
![]() This Product
Apple AirTag | |||||
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Awards | A Just-In-Case Model | Best Overall GPS Collar | A Subscription-Free Option | ||
| Price | $29 List | $69 List Check Amazon (on sale!) | $99 List Check Price at Amazon/a> | $100 List Check Amazon (on sale!) | $230 List Check Price at Amazon |
Overall Score ![]() |
|||||
| Star Rating | |||||
| Bottom Line | A familiar gadget used to keep track of keys or bags, which can also be used with your dog, though it works best in city settings | Whether needing dependable GPS or in-depth health analysis, this dog tracker tops the charts | As a small and robust dog collar, this can handle whatever your dog puts it through | A simple way to keep track of your dog with an easy setup and straightforward features | If you're hunting for a less-pricey option, this GPS collar is worth looking into if your dog is unlikely to run off |
| Rating Categories | Apple AirTag | Tractive | Fi Series 3 | PetLink | Pit Pat |
| GPS Reliability (35%) | |||||
| Features (20%) | |||||
| Ease of Use (20%) | |||||
| Construction Quality (15%) | |||||
| Size (10%) | |||||
| Specifications | Apple AirTag | Tractive | Fi Series 3 | PetLink | Pit Pat |
| Unique Features | Uses Bluetooth for location, can be used to locate other personal items, no subscription required, incredibly light and small | Monitors vital signs, sleep and bark tracking, health notifications, remotely can light up, remote beeps for recall, easy to add other owners or dog walkers, connected with three cell providers | GPS and LTE testing on-demand, sleeping tracking, sallelite imagery recording for walks, step counter, can add dog walkers or sitters to the app, in-app dog park locators, can run self-diagnostics, can create and name multiple geo fences. | Live updates on GPS accuracy range, can triangulate with cell phones and wifi networks, decent health tracking | No subscription required, health tracking parses activity types, easy to log walks, live signal strength updates |
| Subscription Required | No | Yes | Yes | Yes | No |
| Geofence | No | Yes | Yes | Yes | No |
| Monthly Subscription Cost with 1 year plan | N/A | $9.00/month | $15.75/month | $8.25/month | N/A |
| Monthly Subscription Cost with 2 year plan | N/A | $6/month | $14.12/month | $6.25/month | N/A |
Our Analysis and Test Results
We put the AirTag on our pups and left it on for weeks. We also carried out separate location tests (without losing any pets) to examine its accuracy when finding your pet. While not as reliable in remote areas, an AirTag is more likely to be located when there are more people around. This could be a perfect option for those who live in the city and have a well-behaved dog, and the owner just wants a little extra peace of mind.
GPS Reliability
This device does not use GPS as a location finder, and it can't be located if it isn't within Bluetooth range of an iPhone or iPad. Our testing found this device to be fairly reliable in cities where the tag came into frequent contact with other smart devices, but in rural areas, it didn't work at all.
The AirTag is first and foremost an item locator that can serve as a phenomenal resource when finding your keys or a bag, but it was not designed to locate animals, or kids (Yes, we've heard of people actually doing this. No, we do not recommend it). In the context of finding your dog, it must be in a city setting if you want any sort of reliability. For dog owners who live in this setting and have a dog that sticks with them all the time, the low price point and lack of subscription might make this a worthwhile option for that unexpected day your pup goes rogue. When in Bluetooth range, the AirTag was easy to locate with the “Find My” app, which can also be set up to locate your cell phone, laptop, and iPad. This is a plus for Apple product users: having all your devices and pet locations in the same app can be convenient.
Features
The AirTag is a no-frills device that can only be located; other devices can keep track of sleep, activity, and even vitals. However, some shoppers may not mind the bare-bones design.
The AirTag is good for one thing and one thing only: locating whoever or whatever it is attached to, as long as it's near an Apple device. The “Find My” app from Apple is easy to use, and it even notifies you if an AirTag has left home, similar to a normal GPS collar's ability to notify you if your pup has left the geofence. Besides these basics, there's not much else to the AirTag.
Ease of Use
Ease of use for this device depends heavily on which device you have: an Android user won't be able to truly use the AirTag, as it only works with an iPhone.
When locating the AirTag (in a city), it was reliable and allowed the basic functionality that's essential to a GPS collar. We greatly appreciated the quick setup, though you may need to adjust your privacy settings on your iPhone if you don't already use the “Find My” app for other devices. We also loved the battery life; it can last as long as one year, while most of the competition only lasts 2 weeks or less. However, the AirTag isn't rechargeable, and you'll have to replace its physical battery (CR2032 lithium 3V coin battery) when the time comes.
Construction Quality
The AirTagwasn't designed to track a dog, but Apple built it with an IP67 rating, so it'll handle a one-meter submersion and is dust-tight. We did our best to break the AirTag, but it made it through the entirety of our testing with relative ease. Despite its sleek design, this thing is burly.
The AirTag is a durable device, but doesn't come with a dog collar attachment. Thankfully, there are many options online for an AirTag attachment from third-party sellers. We were glad Apple designed this model to be tough on its own, which allowed the collar attachment to be less protective. Though we still recommend that you consider the security of the attachment… if the AirTag falls off the collar, you can't find your pup electronically.
Size
We loved the tiny size of the AirTag. On its own, it's one of the smallest options in this category, though in practice it's not quite as small once you add in the bulk of the separately sold collar attachment.
Even with a collar attachment, the AirTag weighs only .90 ounces. And this is with the attachment we chose for our pup; you'll be able to find even lighter attachments online if this is a priority for you. On its own, the AirTag is about the size of a quarter, making it a great option for shoppers who have a small dog.
Should You Buy the Apple AirTag?
For its price, the AirTag offers unbeatable value, but it comes with some crucial asterisks. We only recommend using this device on your dog if they're unlikely to run away and you live in a city where there's likely to be an iPhone or iPad nearby. Remember, these only work if they're near a Bluetooth-enabled Apple device. If this device sounds like it'll work for your needs, its low price and lack of subscription will carry your dollar incredibly far.
What Other GPS Dog Collars Should You Consider?
If you like the idea of a subscription-free design but want more consistent GPS reliability than the AirTag, consider the Pit Pat Dog GPS tracker, which has its own SIM card and even offers some basic health analytics. If you want a more dependable device that boasts excellent scores across the board, take a look at the Tractive GPS, though it requires a subscription.
—Zach Lovell













