Hamilton Beach Easy Reach 4-Slice Review

The Hamilton Beach Easy Reach 4-Slice is able to do most basic cooking tasks well and does so at a great price. You can't fit huge portions in this compact oven, but what does fit inside will be cooked or baked consistently better than what you'd expect from such an inexpensive oven. In fact, it received higher scores than some bigger, fancier models with double or triple the price tag.

Performance Comprison

Cooking Performance

Plan on using a bit more cook time than the directions call for when baking with the Easy Reach toaster oven. Our cookies were all a bit undercooked when the recommended baking time was up. In fact, they required nearly double the recommended time. Despite the extra baking times, the end product was generally very pleasing — slightly darker than we desired but still very moist and tasty. Most of the frozen items we heated came out a little undercooked after the recommended cooking time, as well. The tater tots we cooked in the Easy Reach had a hard, crispy exterior, and soft exterior that was too dry for our liking.

The pizza we cooked with the Easy Reach was bubbly with good color on the crust. Due to its compact size, this toaster oven barely accommodates a 9-inch pizza, while many other ovens we tested could fit a standard-size 12-inch pizza. If tater tots are your thing, this oven will struggle to fit half a bag's worth. On the bright side, once we learned the subtleties of this oven, we were consistently able to produce frozen meals that were acceptably cooked. We simply had to wait a little longer than the directions suggested.

Toasting Performance

As its name denotes, it can toast four slices of bread at once. Most of the toasting was uniformly golden brown. However, the back left side of the oven routinely toasted a little lighter than the rest of the oven. While the shade settings are somewhat unclear on the dial, the toast still came out a good medium to dark golden brown with a lighter center and a somewhat squishy texture.

We found the same heating map inconsistency when toasting bagels. The oven is only big enough to toast two full bagels at a time. The half-bagel slices in the front toasted perfectly, while those in the rear of the oven were paler and less crispy. Overall, the Easy Reach earned slightly above-average marks for toasting and we feel it does an acceptable job with this metric.

Ease of Use

We found the Easy Reach fairly simple to use and quite easy to clean. The feature we liked the most was the oven's roll-top opening, which not only frees up counter space but also gives the Easy Reach its name. Most toaster ovens either swing open to the side, like a microwave, or swing down, like a conventional oven. The Easy Reach's door rolls up and over the oven. This exposes more than two-thirds of the interior oven, much like an outdoor BBQ grill.

The roll-top feature allows the user to access items by reaching down to them, making it much easier to adjust or remove food without bumping into the oven or burning your hands. Many toaster ovens have very little space between the racks and the interior sides of the oven, making it challenging to adjust or remove food. We liked the fact that the Easy Reach's door is completely clear, which allowed us to monitor all of our food in one glance. We also love that the entire door can be removed for easy cleaning.

For this metric, we gave the Easy Reach its highest marks for ease of cleaning. Its crumb tray is very functional and easy to use. Likewise, cleaning out the oven's interior is a breeze — another benefit of the roll-top door. When open, the oven is completely accessible, both visually and spatially, which allows fingers, rags or scrubbers to easily find their way into every corner.

However, the Easy Reach didn't score as well on the ease of its interface. Although consisting of only two simple knobs, the oven's operation isn't overly intuitive or as simple to use as it appears. It was hard to tell which shade you are selecting for toasting. That said, it's not overly complicated, but a few peeks at the owner's manual helps. As for accessories, this oven comes with a baking pan, oven rack, and slide-out crumb tray.

Temperature Accuracy

During our tests, we strategically placed calibrated thermometers inside the oven. After setting the oven to 350 degrees Fahrenheit, we allowed the oven to preheat and then checked the temperature at timed intervals. The Easy Reach was very consistent in these tests, showing an average of 5.1 degrees under the set temp of 350F — one of the most accurate models we tested.

This toaster oven took an average of 2.4 minutes to preheat to 350F in our tests, which was about average in our test lineup.

The results of our temperature accuracy testing corresponded closely to our overall experiences in baking and cooking. In general, we found the Easy Reach undercooked items, which required additional cooking time to be added. However, there's a small upside: We feel it's better for things to be undercooked than overcooked. Even though we had to wait a little longer for our pizzas or cookies, we were happy to find that most items were eventually cooked to very acceptable standards with little or no burned areas.

Should You Buy the Hamilton Beach Easy Reach 4-Slice?

Cooking large dishes or gourmet meals will never happen with the Hamilton Beach Easy Reach 4-Slice. Its compact design lends itself to one-and-done, single-serving dishes. You should buy this toaster if you're looking to save money and don't need a large, multi-function oven. This toaster is designed to toast, bake simple snacks, reheat leftovers, or cook small, pre-made frozen meals. It's great for after-school goodies and would also be perfect for a college student or someone living the studio apartment life.

We also see a place for the Easy Reach in an adventure van or other type of RV. It takes up little space and is lightweight, simple to use and to clean. Most appealing about this oven is its lower price tag. When we combine its lower price with its ability to compete with higher-priced models, we feel the Easy Reach is a great buy.

What Other Toaster Oven Should You Consider?