Breville Bit More 2 Slice Review

The Breville Bit More 2 Slice may not be the absolute best option for all-around toasting performance, but it does make a killer waffle, has a sleek overall appearance with a fun interface, and several interesting features.

Bread Toasting

When it comes to toasting bread, the Breville Bit More delivers mixed but generally positive results. On the light setting, the bread barely changes color, and even if you prefer just a hint of warmth in your bread, you might need to experiment with the level 2 setting instead. Fortunately, the Breville passed our level 2 heat test, successfully achieving that elusive gently toasted result — crispy with light gold coloring — that many toasters struggle to deliver on their lowest settings.

The medium setting is where the Breville begins to show up. Our test slices achieved appealing golden coloration with a satisfying crunch. However, we noticed that one corner of each slice didn't heat as evenly as the rest. This quirk appeared in every test cycle, suggesting it's a design characteristic rather than a one-off defect. Despite this minor inconsistency, the overall results on medium were pleasing.

Results from the dark setting confirm the uneven heating pattern. While most of each slice achieves a rich, dark brown color that serious toast lovers crave, one problematic corner remains noticeably lighter with dark gold coloring instead. The good news is that this toaster delivers these results consistently — you can count on the same performance every time, even if that performance includes predictable unevenness.

Bagel Toasting

Bagel lovers will appreciate the Breville's dedicated bagel setting. It works by reducing power to specific heating elements, toasting the cut side while gently warming the outer crust.

The bagel setting performs admirably, creating that ideal contrast between a crispy, golden interior and a warm, soft exterior. The same slight unevenness we noticed with regular bread appears here too, but it is less noticeable given the irregular surface of bagels. The toaster handled both fresh and day-old bagels well, reviving slightly stale bagels to near-fresh quality.

We found the bagel setting particularly effective with thicker, New York-style bagels, which can be challenging for toasters with shorter slots. The Breville's slots accommodated these heartier breakfast options without issue, though extremely thick artisanal bagels might still require some careful positioning.

Frozen Waffle Toasting

Frozen waffles present a unique challenge for toasters — achieving a crispy exterior while ensuring the interior is thoroughly heated is not always easy, but the Breville Bit More includes a dedicated frozen setting that adjusts the toasting cycle to account for the additional moisture and cold temperature of frozen items.

Our frozen waffle tests revealed solid performance. This toaster produces waffles that are crispy on the outside and warm throughout. The frozen setting effectively prevents the common problem of waffles that are burnt on the edges but still cold in the middle. We achieved our best results using the frozen setting on medium shade, which delivers golden-brown waffles with satisfying crunch.

The texture achieved was notably better than simply using a higher heat setting without the frozen function. The adjusted cycle allows for more gradual heating, which helps maintain the waffle's structural integrity while achieving thorough warming. Kids and adults alike enjoyed the results, though perfectionists might notice the same slight corner unevenness that appeared in our bread tests.

Ease of Use

Beyond toasting performance, the Breville Bit More disappears into your morning routine because it is so easy to use. The standout feature is undoubtedly the “Lift and Look” function — a simple innovation that solves an age-old breakfast dilemma. By pressing the lever up during toasting, you can check your bread's progress without interrupting the heating cycle. This feature has saved countless slices from over-toasting in our kitchen.

The LED display provides clear feedback about settings and remaining time, making it easy to achieve consistent results. The five shade settings offer a reasonable range, though we found ourselves using settings 2-4 for most items. The control buttons are responsive and intuitive, with clear labels for each function.

Cleaning the Breville is straightforward thanks to a removable crumb tray that slides out easily from the front. The smooth stainless steel exterior wipes clean with minimal effort, though it does show fingerprints (like most stainless appliances). The interior can be accessed by turning the toaster upside down, and the heating elements are positioned to minimize crumb accumulation.

With a measured 880 watts (Breville reports 900 watts), the toaster provides adequate power without being an energy hog. Toasting two slices on medium takes approximately 2.5 minutes — neither the fastest nor slowest in our testing, but reasonable for daily use.

Should You Buy the Breville Bit More 2 Slice?

The Breville Bit More makes sense for households that value smart features and consistent performance over absolute toasting perfection. The “Lift and Look” feature and intuitive controls create a premium user experience that justifies the higher price for many buyers. This toaster particularly suits those who appreciate good design and are willing to adapt to its minor quirks. Home cooks who frequently toast various items will appreciate the dedicated settings and reliable performance across different modes.

What Other Toaster Should You Consider?

If budget is a primary concern, the Black+Decker 2-Slice T2569B delivers impressive toasting performance at a fraction of the Breville's price, earning our Best Budget award with more even browning across the entire slice. For those seeking ultimate versatility, the Ninja ST100 Foodi 2-in-1 Flip Toaster offers both toasting and compact oven functionality, though with some compromise in pure toasting performance. If aesthetics and premium construction matter most, the Smeg 2-Slice toaster brings Italian design flair to your countertop while delivering excellent, even toasting, though it comes with an even higher price point than the Breville.