Makita 18V LXT Brushless Cordless 1/2" Driver-Drill XFD14Z Review
Our Verdict
Compare to Similar Products
| Awards |  Best Drill For Most People | Best for Serious DIYers or Professionals |  Best Compact 5-in-1 Drill |  Best Budget Drill | |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Price | $189 List Check Price at Amazon | $120 List Check Price at Amazon | $180 List Check Amazon (on sale!) | $155 List Check Price at Amazon | $125 List Check Price at Amazon |
Overall Score  |
|||||
| Star Rating | |||||
| Bottom Line | This tool is great for most heavy-duty projects but struggled a bit with the larger hole saws | This drill contains potent power in a compact package, especially for a 20-volt model | This tool delivers excellent performance across the board and is a stellar option for both DIYers and professionals | This is a compact, convenient, and very capable 12 volt drill that won't disappoint | Battery life and solid performance make this a good choice for average homeowner tasks |
| Rating Categories | Makita 18V LXT Brush... | Dewalt Atomic 20-Vol... | Milwaukee M18 Fuel 1... | Dewalt Xtreme 12V 5-... | Bosch 18V Compact Br... |
| Drilling (30%) | |||||
| Driving (25%) | |||||
| Ease of Use (25%) | |||||
| Battery Life (5%) | |||||
| Weight (15%) | |||||
| Specifications | Makita 18V LXT Brush... | Dewalt Atomic 20-Vol... | Milwaukee M18 Fuel 1... | Dewalt Xtreme 12V 5-... | Bosch 18V Compact Br... |
| Battery Voltage | 20V | 20V | 20V | 12V | 18V |
| Motor Type | Brushless | Brushless | Brushless | Brushless | Brushless |
| Measured Weight | 4.5 lb | 3.2 lb | 4.2 lb | 2.1 lb | 2.8 lb |
| Five Inch Hole Saw Test | 17 seconds | 21 seconds | 11 seconds | 40 seconds | 56 seconds |
| Lag Screw Test | 5.0 in | 4.8 in | 5.0 in | 4.1 in | 3.4 in |
| Max Chuck | 1/2 in | 1/2 in | 1/2 in | 3/8 in | 1/2 in |
| Included Battery Pack(s) | Tested with 2.0 Ah | 2.0 Ah | Tested with 2.0 Ah | 2.0 Ah | 2.0 Ah |
| Manufacturer Peak Torque | 1,250 in-lbs | 404 UWO | 1400 in-lbs | 182 in-lbs | 400 in-lbs |
| Measured Charge Time | 23 min | 47 min | 25 min | 55 min | 63 min |
| Measured Length | 7.0 in | 5.9 in | 6.9 in | 6.5 in | 6.3 in |
| Clutch Settings | 21 | 15 | 16 | 15 | 20 |
| Manufacturer Stated RPM | Low: 0 - 550 High: 0 - 2100 |
Low: 0 - 450 High: 0 - 1650 |
Low: 0 - 500 High: 0 - 2100 |
Low: 0 - 400 High: 0 - 1500 |
Low: 0 - 500 High: 0 - 1900 |
| Drill Model Tested | XFD14Z | DCD794 | 2903-20 | DCD703 | GSR18V-400 |
| Box Model (Kit) Tested | Tested tool-only, no kit | DCD794D1 | Tested tool-only, no kit | DCD703F1 | GSR18V-400B12 |
| Battery Indicator Location | Battery | Battery | Battery | Battery | Battery |
| LED Location | Above the trigger | Above the battery | Above the battery | Above the battery | Above the battery |
| Included Belt Clip | Yes | Yes | Yes | Yes | Yes |
Our Analysis and Test Results
Some nice features about the Makita 18V LXT Brushless Cordless Drill are the included clamp-on handle and the shorter length. The clamp-on handle makes it easier to hold the drill when using larger drill bits, and the shorter length can be very handy when using the drill in more confined areas.
Drilling
This drill got off to a fantastic start with the 1-inch paddle bit. It punched through the stacked boards — even in high gear — and never really caught or struggled to break through as it completed each hole.
The Makita XFD14Z also did quite well with the twist drills on the steel sheets. It only took around 1.5 seconds to drill a ¼-inch hole and didn't stall or catch at all. It struggled a bit more with the ½-inch drill, requiring us to drop down to the lower gear and take around 10 seconds to drill the hole.
Unfortunately, we found the performance of the Makita XFD14Z plummeted with the large hole saw compared to other top-ranked drills. This drill managed to achieve the full depth of the hole saw but struggled in its higher gear. It did better when dropped to the lower gear, taking around 20 seconds to complete the task, but we found the battery depleted after just the one hole, significantly hurting our opinion of this tool.
Driving
Our next round of tests rated and ranked how each cordless drill was driving in fasteners. The Makita XFD14Z did exceptionally well, earning one of the best scores of the entire group.
This drill easily drove a large lag screw to the full depth, making it about half of the way in high gear, then easily finished it off in the lower gear. This test was through a 2x4 into a 4x4 on end, with an appropriate pilot hole drilled.
As expected, it also did very well with the standard wood screws. It can easily drive them to their full depth with just a bit of pressure. It also offers a decent amount of control when it comes to getting the screw heads flush, though we did find a few other drills that were just a bit better in this regard. The adjustable clutch has 21 different torque settings, making it easy to set not to overdrive or strip any fasteners.
Battery Life
Our next set of tests looked at how efficiently each of these power tools utilizes their cordless battery capacity. We purchased the Makita XFD14Z as a tool-only product, so we conducted these tests with a 2 amp-hour Makita battery — comparable to the type of battery most other products include when purchased as a kit. We based scores on a side-by-side usage comparison and the time it took for a battery to recharge with the stock charger. This Makita did very, very well, earning it a top-tier score.
The XFD14Z completed nine full cycles of our battery draining assessment, dying on the 10th. However, it did manage to drive in all the screws and drill half of a hole on the 10th cycle. This cordless drill also easily managed these tasks in the higher gear for all but the 1-inch holes on the last full set. This is one of the best battery performances we have evaluated to date.
On top of all that, we love how fast this battery recharges. In our tests, the factory charger fully topped off a completely depleted 2 amp-hour battery in approximately 25 minutes — significantly better than the hours it took some of the other chargers for a similarly-sized battery.
Convenience
The Makita XFD14Z delivered solid results in the convenience department, earning it an above-average score. This drill has two different speed modes, and the chuck can adjust to hold a bit with a maximum of a ½-inch shank. We love that you can turn on the integrated light without starting the drill and found it quite effective in tight, dark spaces. It provides decent illumination, with only a shadow above the drill bit.
The drill feels plenty comfortable to hold, though it is a bit on the heavier side, tipping the scales at about 4 pounds, 7.7 ounces. The XFD14Z includes a belt clip, and the batteries have a built-in indicator, though we weren't fans of the increased force it took when inserting or removing a battery.
Should You Buy the Makita XFD14Z?
Overall, we think the Makita XFD14Z is a great cordless drill. It gets the job done, scoring very well in most of our tests. Our main complaint was the battery dying during our 5-inch hole saw test, but we found very little to take issue with besides that. It efficiently uses battery power and does a great job driving in fasteners, all while being convenient and easy to use. While the Makita XFD14Z is one of the top-tier performers, it also comes with a top-tier price tag. It isn't the best value option, particularly if you aren't tackling heavy-duty drilling or driving applications projects.
What Other Drill Should You Consider?
The best of the bunch is the Milwaukee M18 Fuel 1/2" Drill Driver, and it is slightly less expensive. With better drilling performance and a lighter weight, it could be a better tool depending on your goals. If budget is a concern, the Craftsman V20 1/2-In. Drill/Driver Kit CMCD700C1 is significantly less expensive, but it has some sacrifices in driving and battery life, and offers equal performance for drilling and convenience. Depending on project plans and how you will use your new drill, the cheaper model might be all you need.
—David Wise and Austin Palmer
