We buy all the products we test — no freebies from companies. If you purchase through our links, we may earn a commission, which helps support our testing.
After extensively researching over 50 of the best dog collars currently available, we bought the 13 most compelling options to test out side-by-side and help you find the best for your trusty canine companion. We went on dozens of walks with dogs big and small, rating and scoring how much work it took to adjust and how convenient each collar was to use. We looked at how durable, stylish, and easy to clean each collar is, including which ones stayed smelling the nicest. Read on to find out which dog collar we crowned the winner, which is the best for pullers, our favorite martingale model, and more.
Over the years, we've tested several Ruffwear products and always find them to be durable and constructed with quality in mind. For folks with big dogs or pullers, we love the Martingale-style Ruffwear Web Reaction. The prints are fashionable and fun, and we appreciate the aluminum V-ring leash anchor with a separate dedicated tag loop. The asymmetrically shaped ring is less likely to get snagged and bend than a circle ring, and the included silicone tag reduces noise by placing it between metal. We were pleased to learn that this collar is extremely easy to clean and that the material is not prone to holding on to nasty smells after one simple wash.
There is a drawback to the thin material of the Web Reaction — it's not as durable as collars made with leather or thicker webbing. We love the available color options, especially the color we chose for testing, but there are few to choose from compared to other models offered in dozens of colors or have the option to customize. Ruffwear also makes some non-Martengale styles, but the company discontinued the one we previously awarded in our review. Overall, we think the Web Reaction is the way to go for a great-looking Martingale collar that is easy to clean and easy to use.
The attractive Ruffwear Web Reaction Martingale dog collar is great for dogs that pull.
For a simple webbing collar that won't empty your wallet, we recommend the Blueberry Classic Adjustable. Our testers found it flexible, easily adjustable, and quick to put on and take off. However, as with any webbing collar, if your dog gets their teeth into it while not wearing it, it might not survive too long. This collar also performed well in our odor absorption test and didn't retain any odors after a wash.
Compared to some of the flashier patterned options, the Blueberry Classic won't make a huge style statement, but we still appreciate the fact that it is available in multiple colors. At a similar price point, you may also consider adding a little bit of personalization and greater reflectivity with the GoTags Personalized Reflective or the PAWBLEFY. The denser webbing of the Blueberry Classic held on to water just a bit more than some other collars we tested, and if completely soaked through, it took a tad longer to dry out. Bottom line, this is an excellent choice for anyone shopping on a budget and seeking a traditional solid-color webbing option for their dog.
Martingale dog collars offer an added degree of control when your dog is on a leash. The self-cinching design gently tightens if your dog is tugging too hard and also keeps them from backing out of their collar. If this sounds like a feature that you and your furry friend could benefit from, the PetSafe Martingale Quick Snap is our recommendation for an inexpensive Martingale. Our team found this model very easy to adjust, and the plastic buckle is as easy as it gets when it comes time to remove the collar. Odors also completely disappeared for us with one wash cycle.
We had very little gripes about the Quick Snap. And yet, we also didn't find anything particularly impressive about it either. Overall, this dog collar is very average looking. If you're searching for a snazzy collar to give your fuzzball some extra style, you'll have to splurge a little more for a fashionable look. So, if you are willing and able to spend just a bit more to get some really nice aesthetics and additional features, consider the attractive and effective Ruffwear Web Reaction. Compared to other burlier models tested, we noticed that the Quick Snap also has less stitching, leading us to suspect that it might not hold up for dogs who tend to play hard. Complaints aside, this is an excellent option for a Martingale collar that will hardly put a dent in your wallet.
The PetSafe Martingale Quick Snap is an affordable and effective no pull collar.
Material: Webbing | Available Colors/Patterns: 5 base colors, 15 thread options
REASONS TO BUY
Clear and easy-to-read embroidery
Easy to clean and odor-resistant
REASONS TO AVOID
Fewer base colors to choose from
Reflective strip can show wear
The GoTags Personalized Reflective is our top pick for anyone seeking a customized collar. You can get a total of 25 characters embroidered on it, which should be enough space for most pet names and a phone number, eliminating the need for a separate ID tag with contact information. There are five different base colors to choose from, with 15 separate thread choices to customize. We love how easy this collar is to put on and remove from a dog's neck, and we appreciate that it didn't hold on to any residual odors during our testing.
Pure webbing collars offer a lot of flexibility, and we noticed that the embroidery and reflective strip of the GoTags Reflective reduce that flex, which we assume will be more noticeable on smaller sizes than the larger ones. Dirt, scuffs, and scrapes also all appeared rather quickly on the reflective strip, but after a quick wash, the brightness returned fast. This is a great choice for those who tend to take their pet out on early morning or late evening walks when high visibility is of the utmost importance. It's also a good option if you want to minimize the number of jangly ID tags on your dog's collar. If you want a customizable collar and you like the look of leather, we recommend the Custom Catch Personalized.
The GoTags Personalized Reflective collar is a great way to keep your furry friend easily recognizable while also keeping them safer at night.
The PAWBLEFY Personalized Reflective Nylon is an exceptional safety product for your dog, especially in the blaze orange color we tested. It doesn't offer any truly groundbreaking or revolutionary features but instead utilizes a combination of simple, high-visibility parts and materials that make it easy to see your dog, especially in low-light situations. The personalized aspect of this collar, combined with the reflective stitching in the already highly visible blaze orange nylon, as well as matching blaze orange hardware and personalized tag, sets it apart from standard dog collars.
We tested the PAWBLEFY Personalized Reflective Nylon while upland game hunting and on nighttime walks, and really liked the safety this collar adds by improving how quickly and easily you can identify your dog in tall grasses, thick sagebrush, and low light situations. We think the nylon material could be slightly improved, like the treated tight weave of the Ruffwear Web Reaction, and it would also be nice if it was redesigned to be a no-pull collar. Despite these critiques, we highly recommend this dog collar as a great budget-friendly way to increase your furry friend's safety.
The very visible and reflective PAWBLEFY Personalized Reflective Nylon Dog Collar.
If you routinely walk your dog at nighttime and want to add a little more visibility, then we recommend the Illumiseen LED Rechargeable. This collar cleverly hides its battery and LED light source in a small enclosure sandwiched between layers of webbing and then uses a pair of flexible fiber-optic tubes to light up almost the entire length of the collar. It's flexible, easily conforming to your pet's neck, and is easy to take on and off. The plastic buckle, leash attachment, and stitching all seem solid and secure.
The manual claims the Illumiseen is splash and moisture-resistant, but it also states that this collar shouldn't be submerged. Therefore, you will need to consider another option if your dog likes swimming. It lacks a separate attachment spot for a tag, and our testing proved it isn't the easiest model to adjust in size. In addition, we weren't impressed that the Illumiseen uses a proprietary charging cable instead of a standard one, so if you lose it, you will have to purchase another one directly from the company. All things considered, this model is our favorite LED light-up collar. To add more ability to find and track your dog, consider using one of the Bluetooth Trackers we tested. If LEDs are just a bit too much, or your dog likes getting wet, but you still would like to improve your dog's safety, you might consider the PAWBLEFY Personalized Reflective Nylon.
The Illumiseen LED Rechargeable has a thick strap and a solid buckle but cannot be submerged in water.
Credit: Ross Patton
Compare Products
Broadus and Boo think the Ruffwear and Wolfgang models are the best.
Credit: Ross Patton
How We Test Dog Collars
To test and rank these collars, we went on walk after walk, then more walks, and then even more walks. We tested their visibility and reflectivity by conducting walks in the evenings and at nighttime, as well as taking a couple of dogs on upland game hunts that last until dusk, where visibility and safety are of the utmost importance. We evaluated the closure mechanisms and timed how smoothly they operated, and we assessed each collar's wear and tear, checking for weak points or unraveled stitching. The score for each dog collar was determined via testing across four key metrics:
Ease of Adjustment (30% of overall score weighting)
Durability (30% weighting)
Ease of Cleaning (20% weighting)
Aesthetics (20% weighting)
Why Trust GearLab
With the number of dogs, dog owners, and outdoorsmen that frequent GearLab, we had plenty of experience to draw on for this review. Our dog collar testing and review process was headed up by David Wise, Ross Patton, and Ben Hickok. Between the three of them, they have tested hundreds of home and outdoor products for GearLab ranging from camping gear to power tools and kitchen appliances to fitness equipment. Assisting with this review are David's Newfoundland and Bernese Mountain Dog, Ross's two hounds, and Ben's Catahoula Leopard. They were also joined by a handful of other dogs of all shapes and sizes to help you find the perfect collar for your furry friend.
Checking if this Martingale collar helped curb pulling.
Bear giving the Illumiseen collar a try.
Pacha patiently waiting for the Hoopie's very easy to use snap buckle to be latched before her walk.
Our fuzzy models didn't mind the work it took to put this project together.
Analysis and Test Results
After an exhaustive market research process, we purchased the top contenders and split our head-to-head dog collar tests into four metrics. Standout performances of products in each metric are outlined below.
What's the Best Value?
The elements to consider when shopping for a dog collar in terms of value are style, durability, and functionality. Generally speaking, if you're looking for a certain feature such as personalization, fashionable prints or materials, or components such as extra padding or LED lights, it's going to cost more than a run-of-the-mill collar. If you're looking for a model that's basic and affordable, the Blueberry Classic Adjustable is a good standard version, and the PetSafe Martingale Quick Snap is a great option for a cinching model. The BoomiBoo Reflective Nylon Adjustable was the most affordable collar we tested and offers the bare minimum from a dog collar.
Collars with buckles that clip tend to be easier to put on and remove than models that are styled after a belt.
Credit: Jason Peters
Considering its LED lights and integrated battery, we think the Illumiseen LED Rechargeable is a great deal. If you like the idea of your furry friend's name being stitched on their collar, the GoTags Personalized Reflective is reasonably affordable and includes customization with your purchase. The PAWBLEFY Personalized Reflective Nylon is also very affordable, customizable, and very reflective, but most importantly, it is a simple and affordable way to make your dog much more visible and increase their safety factor at night. The Ruffwear Web Reaction Martingale offers snazzy prints, tough key rings, and silicone tag silencers.
A pile of past collars geared up and ready for walking.
Credit: David Wise
Ease of Adjustment
One of our most important metrics relates to how easy these collars are to use and adjust. We assessed the time it took to take them on and off, how smoothly the buckle or clasp operates, how flexible and conforming each collar is, what sort of leash and tag attachment points there are, as well as how easy each collar is to adjust in circumference.
For convenience, we vastly prefer webbing collars with a snap-style buckle over the ones with a belt buckle closure. In particular, the Ruffwear Web Reaction Martingale and Wolfgang Man & Beast stood out from the other models for their extreme flexibility and ability to conform around our dogs' necks.
The thin webbing of the Ruffwear Web Reaction Martingale makes for quick and easy adjustments.
Credit: Ross Patton
Regarding flexibility, the Blueberry Classic Adjustable, PetSafe Martingale Quick Snap, Joytale Reflective, BoomiBoo Reflective Nylon Adjustable, and PAWBLEFY Personalized Reflective Nylon are about what you'd expect from a traditional synthetic webbing collar, whereas the GoTags Reflective collar is slightly less flexible due to its embroidery.
The embroidery on this collar makes it a little less flexible but Arlo doesn't seem to mind too much.
Credit: Laura Casner
The Country Brook Petz is another snap collar, but it features an all-metal buckle, which didn't latch and unlatch quite as smoothly as some of its plastic competitors. All of the webbing collars, along with the Illumiseen LED Collar, have sturdy D-rings to serve as leash attachment points. The Ruffwear Web Reaction Martingale has a dedicated ID tag loop, so you'll never need to worry about accidentally clipping your leash to the tag instead of the D-ring.
We found the metal buckle on the Country Brook Petz didn't clasp or unclasp quite as smoothly as some of the others.
Credit: David Wise
The embroidered GoTags collars are also very convenient since the customization option eliminates the need for a separate ID tag entirely, so long as you include your phone number in the embroidery. The Black Rhino Comfort Collar and the Custom Catch Personalized both have a belt buckle clasp, which we found to be much less convenient since they take longer to put on. Your size adjustments are also more limited since you must rely on the pre-punched holes for discrete lengths rather than having an entire range available as you do with a sliding adjustment. The Black Rhino is a bit more user-friendly than the other two due to its flexibility.
The belt buckle on the Black Rhino collar can be a bit more of a hassle to use.
Credit: David Wise
The illuminated collar we tested — the Illumiseen — is relatively user-friendly but is a bit more work due to its electronic nature. It can be used as a normal collar, but it's harder to adjust and much less flexible, so we would mainly recommend it for its light-up qualities, and it wouldn't be our first choice for a day-to-day collar.
The Illumiseen truly shines at night, making your pup much more visible.
Credit: David Wise
Durability
To compare and assess durability, we looked at the materials each collar is made of and if they sustained any wear and tear or damage during testing. We pulled as hard as we could on each collar to see if the clasp separated or if anything broke. All of the collars in our review passed the pull test.
With its metal components, thick webbing, and a layer of neoprene, our team found the Black Rhino Comfort Collar to be the most durable of the bunch. The Custom Catch was not far behind with its burly leather construction. In general, leather collars are probably better for dogs who aren't prone to diving into the water at every available chance.
The metal grommets, steel buckle, and thick material of the Black Rhino make it one of the most durable models we've seen.
Credit: Ross Patton
Collars made from webbing are moderately durable, and they all have their strengths and weaknesses. The Ruffwear models are made from fairly thin material, but the weave is tightly knit, and they seem to have a greater sheen to them as if they are coated or treated. They also have bar tacking that is bigger and thicker than that of all other models we tested. The LupinePet Eco 1", Joytale Reflective, and Blueberry Classic Adjustable both have thicker webbing but less stitching. Each of these models uses hard plastic for its buckles, which is very resistant to scratching, wear, and tear.
The Ruffwear materials are tightly woven, and the bartacking is very heavy.
Similar but different clip in points.
While the PAWBLEFY Personalized Reflective Nylon can be customized with your dog's name and phone number, we are a little cautious of the durability of the custom printing onto the silicone-like nameplate material. It's worth noting, that many dog owners will attach other safety information to a collar at a dedicated ID clip or anchor point, such as veterinary information and any other county-required tags, so while customization is nice one of the more important durability aspects of a collar is how securely you can attach tags, regardless of customization features.
All of the other webbing collars emerged from our tests relatively unscathed, but we did see some slight tarnishing on the metal buckle of the Country Brook Petz, as well as some scrapes and scuffs on the plastic Wolfgang Man & Beast buckle. The Man & Beast uses glue rather than stitching to hold the collar together, which makes us a bit skeptical of its longevity. We also noticed slight wear on the reflective strip of the GoTags Reflective, but it seemed minor.
The Wolfgang Man & Beast uses glue rather than stitching.
Credit: Ross Patton
While the Illumiseen does have a relatively beefy buckle and a thick webbing strap, its electronics will be more susceptible to damage from impact or liquids. However, not even the toughest dog collar will stand up to extensive chewing, so it's best to make sure the collar is either snugly worn or safely stored if you want to prolong its life and keep it from becoming the next toy your dog shreds.
The Illumiseen looks like a fairly typical collar by day.
Credit: David Wise
Ease of Cleaning
Our next series of tests focused on how easy to clean each collar is, how long each took to dry, and how prone each one is to absorb smells. To test this, we soaked all of the collars that could be submerged in an apple cider vinegar bath overnight, then ran them through a washing machine on a “Quick Wash” setting without laundry soap so there wouldn't be any fragrances to mask the vinegar. After washing, we smelled each collar and noted how much water they held after the spin cycle, then laid them out in the sun to dry to see if they lost any flexibility.
We couldn't smell the slightest hint of vinegar on the GoTags Personalized Reflective, Man & Beast, Blueberry Classic, or either Ruffwear collars once they came out of the wash, passing this test with flying colors. Most of these collars were also almost completely dry just from the spin cycle, though a few were still damp. The Black Rhino, PetSafe Martingale, Joytale Reflective, LupinePet Eco 1", and Country Brook Petz all had a strong vinegar smell after the washing machine and were quite wet, but the smell mainly dissipated once they had dried. We also found that the PetSafe collar stiffened up a bit more than the others once it baked in the sun.
Here, our doggy models Piper and Milo are wearing the Black Rhino ad the Joytale Reflective.
Credit: Ross Patton
Leather collars like the Custom Catch are notorious for collecting smells and are more susceptible to water damage than webbing collars. Because of this, we skipped our soak test to avoid destroying them. We also skipped soaking and washing the LED collars, given their electronic nature and manufacturer warnings about submerging them.
Collars with electronics such as the Illumiseen cannot be put in a washing machine.
Credit: Ross Patton
Aesthetics
In our most subjective metric, we judged the visual appeal of each collar. We aggregated the opinions of multiple pet owners when comparing looks and considered the number of colors/prints available, as well as any other aesthetic features. Collars with elements such as tag silencers, neoprene padding, reflectivity, or LED lights scored higher than if the same collar lacked these components.
Our team agreed that the Ruffwear Web Reaction Martingale offers the best-looking aesthetics for most people and also works well with the neutral-colored gray buckle. We appreciate the reinforced aluminum leash hoop that is separate from the smaller, more low-profile keyring hoop meant for tags.
Ruffwear collars include an oval-shaped keyring that is resistant to bending and snagging as well as a silicone silencer that goes in between noisy metal tags.
Credit: Ross Patton
The included leash ring on the Web Reaction has a shape that's less likely to snag than a circle, and it includes a silicone tag to be used in between metal tags to reduce jingling.
The Ruffwear Web Reaction is an attractive no-pull dog collar.
Credit: Benjamin Hickok
If you don't find a Ruffwear pattern that you like, the Wolfgang Man & Beast has several other stylish options for those searching for something snazzier.
The Wolfgang Man & Beast is one of our team's favorites when it comes to looks.
Credit: Ross Patton
We appreciate the burly look and added comfort offered by the Black Rhino. The Illumiseen is only offered in a handful of colors, but we awarded it bonus points for its high degree of nighttime visibility.
The Illumiseen makes your dog much easier to see after the sun goes down.
The Black Rhino has an industrial heavy-duty look that might not be for everyone.
Dog collars range from fashionable to functional and everywhere in between.
For those seeking a solid color, the Blueberry Pet Essentials Classic, LupinePet Eco 1", BoomiBoo Reflective Nylon Adjustable, and Country Brook Petz offer the most options. The GoTags Personalized and Custom Catch will be your best bet if you're looking for a custom collar with your pet's name on it. The GoTags collar is only available in five different base colors, but you get 15 different thread color options for the embroidery of your pet's name, which allows you to mix and match to achieve your desired aesthetic.
Shasta showing off one of the many available color combinations of the GoTags.
It's easy to find the perfect match given the variety of thread and color combos available with this GoTags collar.
Embroidering your dog's name and your phone number on the GoTags can eliminate the need for a nametag.
The Custom Catch also allows you to add icons — like paw prints — for some fun visual embellishment. While they don't illuminate, we appreciate the integrated reflective elements of the GoTags Personalized and the Joytale that add a degree of safety while walking your furball at night.
Reflective materials in low light differ in the amount of reflectivity.
Credit: Benjamin Hickok
The PAWBLEFY Personalized Reflective Nylon adds personalization, high daytime as well as low light visibility, and reflective materials to provide just a little more safety for your companions.
Cora wearing multiple collars, including the collar, while searching for upland game.
Credit: Benjamin Hickok
Conclusion
We hope this has been a helpful analysis of the best dog collars on the market and that it helps you find the perfect product. Whether you have a strong puller, an independent work dog, a lap dog, a hiking, climbing, or a hunting companion, there is an option that we are sure will work for you and your four-legged friend.
