Nimbus Microfine Xtra Soft Review

The capable Nimbus Microfine Xtra Soft impressed us through various tests, especially cleaning and comfort. We appreciated the robust handle, which felt easy to hold, and despite the brush head being somewhat on the larger side, it remained effective at cleaning for a variety of mouth sizes.

Tested and Rated

We take toothbrush testing to a deep level. After buying all the models (no free samples), we create a number of intense side-by-side tests to show exactly how these compare. Review Analyst Genaveve Bradshaw let the testing and myself, Ryan White, synthesized the detailed test results into the review below.

Performance Comparison

Cleaning

The Nimbus cleaned our teeth effectively during our testing and was even better than some electric toothbrushes. Cleaning is our most critical metric, making up 40% of the final score. I tested the cleaning ability of each brush in a variety of ways. First, I chewed a pink plaque-disclosing tablet, which shows any plaque build-up in a bright pink hue. Then, I timed myself brushing for two minutes. Before and after photos were also taken to assess the ability of each brush. Finally, I employed an artificial teeth model and spread wet coffee grounds across the teeth and gums. I used each brush to determine how much of the build-up they could remove. I find that this combination of tests produces consistent results for each model with very little to no variability.

The Nimbus Microfine Xtra Soft surprised us with its overall ability to remove plaque without being too harsh on the gums, thanks to the super soft bristles. It managed to clear away all debris with minimal effort within the allotted 2 minutes of brushing. Our teeth felt clean and smooth after brushing. This is definitely one of the better manual toothbrushes you can buy as far as cleaning goes. Electric toothbrushes still reign supreme in the cleaning department (with few exceptions), but if you prefer a manual one, you can't go wrong here.

Comfort

Comfort, a close second to cleaning, holds significant weight, accounting for 30% of the overall score. A comfortable toothbrush is crucial for maintaining consistent dental hygiene. Our testing thoroughly evaluates factors such as the gentleness or harshness of each brush head and its size. Additionally, I assessed the ease or difficulty of gripping the handle. I found these are all vital to the overall experience.

The Nimbus Microfine Xtra Soft is an incredibly comfortable toothbrush to use and is great for those with sensitive gums. While the brush head leans slightly towards the larger side, it is still manageable, even for those with smaller mouths. The ultra-soft bristles offer ample comfort without compromising effectiveness. The handle has a decent thickness, facilitating easy gripping as well. Its hourglass shape and well-placed textured dots ensure a secure hold, preventing any mid-brushing slips. All-in-all, it was an impressive showing from the Nimbus.

Ease of Use

While it's easy to assume that all manual toothbrushes are user-friendly, our thorough testing uncovers their true strengths and weaknesses. I evaluated factors such as the brush head's effectiveness in reaching difficult areas, the ease of keeping handles clean, and their stability on the bathroom counter, even with toothpaste added to the bristles.

I evaluated the ease of cleaning each toothbrush by smearing toothpaste all over the handle and then cleaning it off. I closely examined each handle to identify any nooks or crannies where toothpaste can accumulate. The Nimbus Microfine Xtra Soft proved to be remarkably easy to clean. Despite its grippy texture, I found it rare for gunk to accumulate in those areas. Additionally, the bristles cleaned effortlessly.

Although the brush head is slightly larger, it maneuvers through a typical brushing routine with ease. The diverse bristle lengths effectively reach hard-to-access areas with minimal effort, marking another win for the Nimbus. Moreover, the well-balanced handle ensures it won't tip over when resting on the countertop. If you're in the middle of brushing and need to set the brush down for any reason, you're in luck. Overall, I was pleased with the results across the board.

Customization

This is the only metric where the Nimbus failed to excel. In this metric, I evaluate the customization and features of each model. Anything exceeding a brush head and handle (and, if applicable, a charger for electric models) would be classified as additional accessories. This encompasses tongue scrapers, teeth picks, compatible apps, built-in timers, or any other supplementary attachments. The majority of manual models typically only offer color options within value packs. When purchasing individual brushes, you essentially receive whichever color is available. Therefore, concerning manual toothbrushes, we're examining whether multiple colors are available and if the value packs offer a variety of colors.

Regrettably, the Nimbus Microfine Xtra Soft lacks a tongue scraper or gum cleaner and is exclusively available in a multi-pack of five brushes. Nonetheless, the multi-pack offers various colors, a feature I appreciated, enabling families to distinguish each member's brush.

Should You Buy the Nimbus Microfine Xtra Soft?

If you prefer a manual toothbrush over an electric one, the Nimbus Microfine Xtra Soft stands out as one of the top choices available. Its exceptional cleaning ability alone justifies its affordable price tag, but it surpasses expectations in every category. The only notable drawbacks are the lack of a gum/tongue cleaner and the inability to purchase this model individually, as it's only available in multi-packs. Despite these considerations, it remains a superior option among its competitors. If you desire an effective and affordable toothbrush and prefer to stick with a manual model rather than switching to electric, I believe you won't be disappointed with this offering from Nimbus.

What Other Toothbrushes Should You Consider?

If you're solely looking for a manual toothbrush, the Colgate 360 Sensitive Extra Soft carries many of the same characteristics as the Nimbus but with a slightly lower price tag. It's also great for folks with sensitive mouths, as the bristles are super soft and gentle. Additionally, it carries a tongue scraper. If you're intimidated by the vast array of electric toothbrushes available and a manual model is more in your comfort zone, look into the Philips One. It bridges the gap between the manual and electric world thanks to the hybrid design and gentle vibrations. Finally, if you want to take a tiny step further into the electric realm, the Philips Sonicare 4100 is a streamlined and effective model containing only one button for operation. It also earned top marks for its cleaning ability. For those interested in more simplistic, manual options, check out our comprehensive toothbrush review.